Why is it that there is often something oddly appealing about the idea of violence? Not so much actual violence, but simply the idea of it. Is this a uniquely American thing, derived from our revolutionary and manifest-destiny seeking history? Or is it some fundamentally human impulse? Does everyone feel it occasionally? Are all women attracted to “the bad boy” on some level? Is this fascination a luxury only available to those, like myself, who have been fortunate enough never to experience real violence?
I just find it strange to recognize this part of myself, because I consider myself (mostly) a pacifist, and I can’t imagine raising my hand (much less a weapon) to anyone in violence. I have a HOT temper, but it takes a lot for me even to lash out verbally at someone. (Mostly, I just unload on poor Nate after the fact or yell out my frustrations at stupid drivers who can’t hear me.) Even in self-defense, I don’t know if I’d actually be able to harm another human being; I fear I’d end up on the dead end of a self-defense scenario.
However, I notice that a lot of my entertainment choices are surprisingly violent. I’m a big fan of The Sopranos, 24, and Heroes. I recently saw The Departed and absolutely loved it, much as I did another violent Scorsese classic, Goodfellas. One of my all-time favorite film scenes is the fight early in Good Will Hunting where Will and his friends have a brawl with a group of thugs who’d been verbally harrassing a girl. It’s shown in slow motion, each punch, kick and head snap exaggerated, with Gerry Rafferty’s “Baker Street” playing hauntingly in the background. And last night, I found myself oddly enthralled by The Black Donnellys premier (prompting this post) and was particularly attracted to Tommy, the smart, thoughtful one with a hand of steel but a conflicted soul. Wathcing it, I was reminded of the scene in the aforementioned Goodfellas where Henry violently beats and pistol whips a man who had assaulted his girlfriend, Karen. When Henry gives her the bloody gun to hide, Karen’s voice over says, “I know there are women who would have gotten out the minute their boyfriend gave them a gun to hide. But I didn’t. I got to admit the truth. It turned me on.”
Of course, the difference here is that I am truly only attracted to the idea of violence. If my (purely hypothetical) boyfriend gave me a gun to hide, I WOULD run the other way. Violence in reality scares me to death. But there is something about fictional violence that makes my pulse race a little. And it’s certainly not the gore; I actually turn my head at gore. But I guess if I think about it, the common thread is that I’m attracted to violence with a “good” purpose, like in 24 or Heroes. And that definition extends in some strange way to shows and movies about organized crime because so much of the violence is perpetrated out of a sense of honor. A warped sense of honor, no doubt, but perhaps it’s the Irish in me that finds the idea of defending one’s honor with violence vaguely noble.
In any case, this is something I often ponder when I’ve indulged myself in some violence-laden film or show. It actually bothers me quite a bit because I don’t want to find violence appealing, and because I wonder how much violent entertainment does relate to desensitization, which in turn creates real violence and/or apathy toward real violence. Who knows? But it’s both interesting and disturbing to consider.