….finished off with 25 pages of feel-good, too-perfect crap. That’s how I would describe Wally Lamb’s I Know This Much is True. It’s 997 pages that I devoured in just over a week (at one time in my life, this would have been slow, but a full time job and 2 kids will change that) and it was so great – until it wasn’t.
So here’s my beef. I related so much with a lot of the book. Not in actual fact – I had a very happy, pleasant childhood, and I’ve never dealt with any of the more extreme drama that the protagonist, Dominick Birdsey, dealt with – but in the fact that the past few years of my life have been really tough. Really, really tough. And there have been times where I’ve simply felt the world was out to get me.
Dominick feels the same way. And, like me, he loses his faith in God. Like me, he also struggles a lot with anger. (Although I’d say I’m better at controlling mine. But it’s always there, beneath the surface.) And so I could really relate to his struggle to come to terms with his life and to let go of his anger. To realize that the world ISN’T out to get him, and that his anger isn’t helping anything.
I appreciated how messy and complex life was, and the ways in which he began to take small steps forward. But the problem was the end. Or actually, the problem was that there were NO problems at the end. Every bad thing in his life is suddenly (and sometimes incredibly unrealistically) resolved. In fact, things that weren’t even a problem were resolved – he’s suddenly a rich man! And he suddenly has a cultural identity he didn’t even know he had!
I don’t know. I’m not being very articulate here. All I know is that for the last week or so, I’ve eagerly picked up that book at every opportunity. And although I’ll still treasure the book for the first 872 pages, I did not anticipate that the last time I put it down, I’d be so utterly disappointed.
Edited: I’ve been skimming through the 3 star reviews on Amazon.com to see if other people agree (they do – it’s one of the top two critiques of the book, but there are a vast preponderance of 5 star reviews over any other rating). And I found one reviewer, by C.S. Junker, who managed to say it far better than I did in two short sentences:
“If a writer wants to say something profound about life, he should avoid facile conclusions. He doesn’t have to end it like “Hamlet”, but it doesn’t have to be a fairy tale, either.”











